Saturday, June 30, 2018

The Motherhood of St. Perpetua and St. Felicity

Saint Perpetua's powerful memoir of her final weeks resonates with Christian mothers. Few first-hand accounts from the early martyrs have survived the centuries. Even within that category, Vibia Perpetua's story is unique. She was a North African noblewoman who lived under Roman rule.[1] She was married, and nursing a small baby. She and her pregnant slave, Felicity, became convinced of the truth of Christianity during a time when new converts to the faith faced severe penalties.[2] Before their baptism, they were arrested together with other catechumens and sentenced to death. Her public execution occurred at the public games in the amphitheater in Carthage on March 7, 203 [3] to celebrate the birthday of the son of Emperor Septimius Severus.[4]

Perpetua was a well-educated woman around twenty years old who valued truth and family. She was a favored child of a prominent family. She was at least trilingual, speaking Greek, Punic, and Latin.[5] She owned slaves, including Felicity, who became a close friend. Perpetua married, and eventually bore a son. Around the same time, she and Felicity decided to enter into the church. Soon Perpetua's brother also came to Christ.[6] Perpetua's charismatic personality may have helped her to persuade him to follow God, no matter the cost. 

[Image 1, see footnotes for source] 

Perpetua and Felicity were arrested, along with their fellow catechumens.[7] Thankfully, Perpetua's brother was not targeted by authorities. Her arrest separated her from her child [8], who was “at the breast.”[9] The catechumens were placed on house arrest initially, and then thrown in a dark dungeon prison to await trial. They united in prayer and praise of God, strengthening one another in faith through fellowship.[10] Perpetua emerged as a leader in encouraging the others. Their catechist turned himself in to authorities, and joined the group.

Perpetua writes, “My condition was aggravated by my anxiety for my baby.”[11] Her breasts were swollen and aching.[12] As a mother, I can sympathize with Perpetua’s angst during the period of separation. As I return to work, I am realizing the powerful bond that breastfeeding creates between a mother and child. My workplace is not yet equipped to provide a private place to nurse or pump, and I have not been able to express milk for my child as regularly as I would have liked during training to keep him fed. Yet my difficulties as a working mother pale in comparison to the trials that Perpetua faced during an extended involuntary separation. The physical discomfort of a nursing mother who cannot feed her child was likely compounded by the emotional distress about her baby’s well-being. She also may have worried that her body would stop producing milk for her little one.

By the time that local church members managed to bribe prison officials to secure visitation time with the families, Perpetua’s baby was emaciated [13]. According to Perpetua, he was “already weak with hunger.”[14] Her mother and brother offered words of encouragement to Perpetua in her tribulations as she offered life-giving nourishment to her baby.

Clearly, her family had yet to find a wet nurse or source of milk for the baby during their visit to prison. Perpetua advocated with prison officials for a solution: with their consent, her child would remain in prison with her. Authorities eventually agreed to the arrangement, though Perpetua was in agony in the interim.[15] As she held the baby in her arms, her fears dissipated. Perpetua tells readers, “Being relieved of my anxiety and concern for the infant, I immediately regained my strength. Suddenly, the prison became my palace, and I loved being there rather than any other place.”[16] 

[Image 2]

Her father pleaded with her numerous times to recant her confession of Christianity for the sake of her family. He implored her, “Have pity on your son!”[17] Though she cared deeply for her child, she did not lie to the court or offer sacrifice to false gods. She told the judge simply, “I am a Christian.”[18]

After her final sentencing, her father took the child away from her, refusing to return the baby to her care. Miraculously, both mother and child were delivered of the need to breastfeed. Perpetua observes, “God saw to it that my child no longer needed my nursing, nor were my breasts inflamed. After that, I was no longer tortured by anxiety about my child or by pain in my breasts.”[19] The child was cared for by her family, and God prepared her spiritually for her martyrdom.

At her brother’s suggestion, Perpetua sought revelation from God regarding her fate. Her four ensuing visions gave her comfort and consolation to face her imminent execution.[20] During prayer one day, she was led by the Holy Spirit to pray for her brother Dinocrates, who died of cancer in childhood. She received a vision of him in a place of torment, and interceded for him fiercely for weeks. She then received a vision of his soul in a peaceful place of provision and refreshment. [21] In a sense, she was a spiritual mother to him since her prayers gave him eternal life in God’s presence.[22]

Meanwhile, another mother stood by her side. Felicity’s pregnancy progressed in prison. She was in her eighth month.[23] Their close-knit group of catechumens who had received baptism together looked forward to eternal life with God and the saints in each other’s company. As the scheduled date of their execution approached, it seemed unlikely that she would give birth in time to join her fellow prisoners. Instead, she would be alone in prison without fellowship. With the help of the local church, she found a Christian woman willing to adopt her baby. She began to pray that she had the baby before the date, so that she would not need “to shed her holy and innocent blood among common criminals.”[24] The sentiment was mutual. Perpetua notes, “Her friends in martyrdom were equally sad at the thought of abandoning such a good friend to travel alone on the same road to hope.”[25] On March 5, they asked God for labor to begin. Felicity began to feel contractions, and suffered intensely.[26] A prison guard mocked her, but she boldly retorted that she suffered for Christ, and He would strengthen her to face her martyrdom.[27] Though premature, her newborn daughter survived to be raised in the faith.

Sts. Perpetua and Felicity faced martyrdom together. They were stripped naked and led out only in nets. A narrator kindly added to St. Perpetua’s diary with a record of their martyrdom. He recorded, “How horrified the people were as they saw that one was a young girl, and the other, her breasts dripping with milk, had recently given birth to a child.”[28] Both died in the arena. Their story lived on, maintained by the church. Their prison warden became a believer,[29] and countless others were moved to faith by their testimony of the power of faith. As mothers, they stood together in Christ.



[Image 3] 

[Image 4] 


[Image 5] 

Their story reminds all mothers to keep perspective. When we place Christ first, our families will receive the care they need. It is easy to get wrapped up in the daily cares of raising children. Many mothers set aside full participation in church and prayer as child-rearing claims more attention. The saints offer timeless wisdom as they whisper to us all that eternal life trumps any duty in this life: God will provide. He always has, and he always will. 



Image sources: 

[Image 1] Tracey L. Christianson, "St. Perpetua and St. Felicity print," 2013, https://www.portraitsofsaints.com/collections/saint-fine-art-prints?page=6. 
[Image 3] “Martyrs – Perpetua and Felicity,” http://daybydaywithjesus.com/martyrs-perpetua-felicity/.  
[Image 4] Lacey Baldwin Smith, Fools, Martyrs, and Traitors: The Story of Martyrdom in the Western World (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc, 1997), 88.
[Image 5] Foxe's Christian martyrs of the world; the story of the advance of Christianity from Bible times to latest periods of persecution (1907), https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Foxe%27s_Christian_martyrs_of_the_world;_the_story_of_the_advance_of_Christianity_from_Bible_times_to_latest_periods_of_persecution_(1907)_(14597219839).jpg.


Footnotes: 

[1] Cecil M. Robeck, Jr., Prophecy in Carthage: Perpetua, Tertullian, and Cyprian (Cleveland, OH: The Pilgrim Press, 1992), 1.
[2] Robeck, Prophecy in Carthage, 11.
[3] Robeck, Prophecy in Carthage, 13.
[4] Emanuela Prinzivalli, "Perpetua the Martyr," in Roman Women, ed. Augusto Fraschetti, tr. Linda Lappin (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2001), 118.
[5] Joyce Salisbury, Perpetua’s Passion: The Death and Memory of a Young Roman Woman (New York: Routledge, 1997), 46.
[6] Emanuela Prinzivalli, "Perpetua the Martyr," 122.
[7] Redactor to the Martyrdom of Perpetua, “The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” in In Her Words: Women’s Writings in the History of Christian Thought, ed. Amy Oden (Nashville, Abingdon Press, 1994), 27. Section 2.
[8] Robeck, Prophecy in Carthage, 20.
[9] Redactor, “The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 27. Section 2.  
[10] Perpetua, “The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” in In Her Words: Women’s Writings in the History of Christian Thought, ed. Amy Oden (Nashville, Abingdon Press, 1994), 30. Section 7.
[11] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 27. Section 3.
[12] Lacey Baldwin Smith, Fools, Martyrs, and Traitors: The Story of Martyrdom in the Western World (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc, 1997), 108.
[13] Emanuela Prinzivalli, "Perpetua the Martyr," 123.
[14] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 28. Section 3.
[15] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 28. Section 3.
[16] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 28. Section 3.
[17] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 30. Section 6.
[18] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 30. Section 6.
[19] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 30. Section 6.
[20] Robeck, Prophecy in Carthage, 61 and 93.
[21] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 31. Section 8.
[22] Salisbury, Perpetua’s Passion, 46.
[23] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 33. Section 15.
[24] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 33. Section 15.
[25] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 33. Section 15.
[26] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 34. Section 15.
[27] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 34. Section 15.
[28] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 35. Section 20.
[29] Perpetua, The Martyrdom of Perpetua,” 34. Section 16.


Aquinas, Bonaventure, and the Diverse Complementarity of the Catholic Church


One of the most beautiful aspects of the unity of the Catholic Faith is its astounding inclusiveness, richness, and diversity. There is ample room within the protection of the maternal bosom of Mother Church for innumerable coexistent and complementary rays of the One Truth to shine forth in a plethora of dazzling and enlightening colors. The Saints of the Church, like different facets of one scintillating diamond of truth and goodness, manifest her beautifully diverse unity in their distinct responses to God as they experience and know him.
One can find an excellent example of diverse unity during what have become known as the Middle ages of the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church enjoyed two prominent avenues of theological thought contemporary to this period (yet both enduring in force to this day), which may, at the outset, appear to be mutually opposed: Scholasticism and Mysticism.
Scholasticism rudimentarily explained is rooted in the intellectual pursuit of God. That is to say, the proponent of this Scholastic approach first raises his or her mind to touch God through the aspiration of the soul’s divinely endowed powers of reason and intellect, grasping these in assent to God’s revelation in the Holy Faith. Scholasticism insists that the powers of reason and intellect can never contradict the revelations given by God; for both divine revelation (given in the Sacred Body of Church Tradition) and what can be known about God through the light of humanity’s natural powers both derive from the same God, who is synonymous with the very Truth which he obliges each person of faith to accept. The true Scholastic in his intellectual ascent to God, does not disdain or reject the aspirations of prayerful devotion in the heart to God, but enjoys prayerful encounter with God as following upon his knowledge of God. By beginning in the mind’s ascent to God through the natural powers of reason and intellect, derived from God’s Merciful Love and taken in the light of Holy Faith, the Scholastic finds his heart elevated to intimate encounter with God’s heart. Thus, it is faith and reason working hand in hand, the one never superceding  the other, which are the the beginning of the Scholastic approach to God (the end of course being the greater glory of God).
The Mystic’s approach to God, may be said to be quite different, in its form if not in its final aim. Mysticism, in its purest and truest sense, is never opposed to what springs from the human intellect; the mystic does not reject deeper knowledge of God, nor does he necessarily disdain using his God-given powers of reason to promote a better understanding of him. The difference is in the beginning point from which each (Scholasticism and Mysticism) start. As has been established, Scholasticism begins with the human reason and intellect within the light of Holy Faith, by raising first the mind, thereby to raise the heart also, to touch God’s heart. The Mystic would take this in the reverse, raising the heart first in prayerful devotion which subordinates (with a holy abandonment and entrustment to God) one’s ability to know through reason. The mystic chooses to dive first into the mystery of intimate encounter with God through the raising of the heart in simple, trusting, confident, faith in God, yet without in any way renouncing or relinquishing the powers of his mind; he would be grateful for these powers as purposeful gifts from God’s Providential Love. Still, it is by beginning with the raising of the heart in child-like faith, that the Mystic comes to possess a deeper knowledge of God, taking the investigative powers of reason and intellect as necessary and good but decidedly second. In this way, Mysticism aspires (and attains to) the same aim as Scholasticism: the greater glory of God.
There are two men (now declared Saints) who lived contemporarily to each-other during the Middle Ages, and who may be taken as noteworthy case-studies of the differences and parallels inherent in each of the aforementioned approaches to God; their names are St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Bonaventure. These two men are sometimes studied as though one must choose one or the other as the correct one between them, however they are properly understood as opposite sides of the same coin.
Thomas Aquinas was a member of the Order of Preachers, otherwise known as the Dominican Order, which was begun in the Middle Ages originally in order to squelch the spread of heresy, especially the Albigensian heresy, within Christendom. It was an order which had, as its principle forum, the battlefield of the mind and which took up, as its banner, reason in union with Holy Faith in order to defend the Catholic Church against intellectually based attacks. It is no surprise, then, that Thomas Aquinas was a decided proponent of the Scholastic approach to God. He believed in the merit of Greek philosophers (Aristotle in particular) and married the pronounced distinctiveness of logical Aristotelian reasoning to the study of the divine. His efforts in the defense and advancement of the Holy Catholic Faith are as gargantuan as they are lasting, providing a firm foundation for theological scholars which has not been shaken to this day.

Bonaventure was a member of the Franciscan order, which also sought to counteract heresy, but went about achieving this aim primarily through the exemplary witness of their way of life. The Franciscans (a mendicant order of friars devoted to voluntary poverty in imitation of the Gospel ideal) were an effective antidote to certain growing heretical movements within the Church of the Middle Ages (the Waldensians and the Humilitati) whose attractiveness and force lay in their mutual emphasis on extreme poverty, intended as a reproach to the avaricious corruption evident within the Church. With the clearly rising tide of Scholasticism, Bonaventure sought to reaffirm the prominence of prayerful ‘Mystical’ devotion to God through contemplative meditation culminating in union with God, thus gaining deeper knowledge of God through direct encounter. Thus for Bonaventure, knowledge was the fruit of love. For him, prayerful meditation, immersed in the Holy Spirit, enlightened the mind and lit the heart aflame so that the soul would most surely pierce the mysteries of God. ^1^ 

Thus already one may discern the initial differences between the approaches of the two orders and the two friars described: one taught principally through intellectual defense, the other proved the worth and weight of belief through direct, ‘wordless’ exhortation of example. One ascended to God by utilizing the good of the reason and intellect first, thus arriving at encounter with God in the heart. The other immersed the heart in encounter with God through prayer, thus arriving at the true knowledge of the reality of God.
So the distinctions have been duly established but what do these men (and their philosophies) share in common? There is a traditional heart-warming story about Aquinas and Bonaventure which is illustrative of the relationship between these two men and may lend insight into their apparently disguised similarities of heart. It is said that both Aquinas and Bonaventure were asked by Pope Urban IV to write a hymn in honor of the Eucharist on the occasion of his institution of the Feast of Corpus Christi. It is on this occasion that Aquinas, having been asked to read his rendering first, presented to the Pope and Bonaventure, that incredibly beautiful and lucid hymn which Catholics still sing parts of in honor of the Eucharist: “Tantum Ergo” or “O Salutaris Hostia.” Upon hearing the composition of Aquinas, Bonaventure humbly ripped up his own work in deference to his brother in Christ. 

Here one sees first the love and respect which Bonaventure had for Aquinas. There was no trace of antipathy on his part toward St Thomas for having surpassed himself in crafting so eloquent a testament to the magnificence of the Eucharist. Further, he did not disdain Thomas’ use of the intellect to achieve so noble an aim. The fact is that, for all their differences, they did attain to the same aim. Bonaventure proves this by his humble deference to the gifts he saw in his brother, so that God would be better glorified. Thomas and Bonaventure both sought the glory of God above all else, including their own honor in this world; and each of them respected and rejoiced in the fruits of the gifts God had given to the other. One may begin to see that intense love of God is the common theme among these two holy men and this love extends also to bind (inextricably) their two approaches to God. ^2^
Pope Benedict XVI, in one of his general audiences, added his own insights on the likenesses between the two Saints, however he did so by first seemingly solidifying their unlikeness to each-other. The Pope said that Aquinas and Bonaventure each had (at least nominally) different understandings of the final end of man. Aquinas, would have said that the final end of man is to ‘see God’. Bonaventure, on the other hand, would have said that the final end of man is to ‘love God’. What the Pope concluded is that the two ends espoused by the Saints: ‘to see God’ and ‘to love God’ are ultimately the same thing. If one truly sees God, it must be, as the Scripture says, that he or she is already good (“pure of heart”) or else the vision of God would be obscured. Contrariwise, to love God, is synonymous to seeing and knowing him as he really is because it is impossible to love what is not known. ^3^
All the marvelous Saints, and all the wondrous fruits of God’s gifts evident in them, together attest to the infinitely diverse, yet profoundly simple nature of God. Those of God’s children who are still journeying through this mortal life would be wise to trek along the well-trod way of the Saints of God, taking the wisdom they offered in variegated ways as a pledge of the blessed life to come. It is perhaps fitting to end with a thought from the teaching of the Catholic Church in the Catechism on man’s ultimate goal-the end of all the beautiful and rich diversity within the Church: 
"God draws close to man. He calls him to seek him, to know him, to love him with all his strength. He calls together all men, scattered and divided by sin, into the unity of his family, the Church. … In his Son and through him, he invited men to become, in the Holy Spirit, his adopted children and thus heirs of his blessed life.” ^4^



^1^ Vidmar, John, The Catholic Church Through the Ages (Mahwah, NJ: Paulist Press, 2014), 143-147.
^3^ Pope Benedict XVI, General Audience on Bonaventure and Thomas Aquinas, part 2 (17 March, 2010)
^4^ Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Washington, DC: United States Catholic Conference, 2000), 1.

Image Credits:

https://www.tfpstudentaction.org/resources/forgotten-truths/what-saint-thomas-aquinas-says-about-mohammed-and-islam

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonaventure

http://www.catholickingdom.com/People/Dominique/Archive/inline/FF_17.html

The Dialogue of St Catherine of Siena: A Review




The Dialogue of Catherine of Siena is a marvelous gift of spiritual literature recorded in the
form of a dialogue between Catherine and God, during one of her mystical
experiences- ‘ecstatic encounters’- with him. The Dialogue reads almost like another Gospel, interspersed with responses and petitions on Catherine’s part. With the wealth of wisdom in this relatively short book of 366 pages, her distinction as one of only four women to be honored as Church Doctors is clearly seen. However, Catherine’s merit lies perhaps first in her virtuous humility and keen sense of charity. Her relationship with God, shows in her complete docility to God’s will; Catherine was ablaze with the fiery desire for “God’s honor and the salvation of souls”. She absolutely exemplifies the words of Christ from the Gospel of John which she quoted in the first page of her prologue, “If you love me and keep my word, I will show myself to you, and you will be one thing with me and I with you.”


Catherine’s work is divided into ten chapters, almost all of which build upon each-other, although they can, without too much confusion, be read independently. Her prologue is the only real exception to this rule, as it provides a foundation and an explanatory principle for the entire book. The other chapters are titled: The Way of Perfection, Dialogue, The Bridge, Tears, Truth, The Mystical Body of Holy Church, Divine Providence, Obedience, and Conclusion.
The premise of the entire work (given in the Prologue) are Catherine’s four self-styled, “petitions”, directed to God the Father. The first is for her own growth in holiness, so as to be better able to serve her neighbors, the second is “for the reform of Holy Church”, the  third, for the salvation of the entire world, and the last, for the provision of God’s Providence in regard to a particular (and apparently clandestine) intention of her own. The subsequent chapters of the Dialogue are God’s response to each of her petitions given with beautiful analogies, and great lucidity and specificity. The main focus of the book, is without doubt, Salvation and the way toward it, as God explains in detail to Catherine at her request.
In the first chapter after the prologue, "The Way of Perfection," God responds to Catherine’s desire to amend the offenses committed against his honor and to make reparation for the sins of others through her own sufferings. This desire of hers was introduced in the Prologue and corresponds with her desire that God should be merciful to the world. God explains to Catherine that, any amount of finite suffering can never equal the infinitude of an offense against Himself because he is eternal; yet he assures her that the soul immersed in God is gifted with a share in his own eternally loving desire which (when joined to holy actions) is therefore beneficial for the salvation of souls.
In this first substantial chapter, God continues in a discourse on the way to become perfect, in response to Catherine’s first petition; many themes are introduced which are referred to quite frequently throughout the entire work. One important element is God’s explanation of the soul’s three God-given and salvation oriented powers: memory, understanding, and will, which are intended as a great help to salvation and are all interconnected. Another recurrent theme introduced in this chapter, is that there is no virtue or vice that does not “come to birth” through interactions with one’s ‘neighbors’. The last large theme of this chapter is God’s use of the analogy of a tree to aid in Catherine’s understanding of the relations between the virtues. Knowledge of self- joined to knowledge of God, the role of discernment, charity, humility, and patience are all shown to be deeply intertwined.
The next chapter, “Dialogue,” contains a great deal of intimate discussion concerning God’s mercy. Here, Catherine, really does seem to be “one thing” with God in her love and desire for souls. This chapter showcases Catherine’s intensely loving relationship with God. The most strikingly beautiful aspect of this relationship, is the way in which God, because of his Love for Catherine, allows himself to be bound by her desire for souls. The conversation sways back and forth between them with Catherine begging for God’s mercy for the world and God yielding to her bold yet humble requests. God expresses how greatly he desires to be merciful to the world through the grief-stricken tears of his servants.
In the third chapter, “The Bridge," God further enlightens

Catherine (by means of analogy) on the way to salvation. Jesus Christ is described as a Bridge which “stretches from heaven to earth.” God explains to Catherine that the Bridge of Christ has three steps which correspond to three stages of the soul along its path to beatitude. These are the feet, side, and mouth of Christ on the Cross. The feet are the first step because the feet are the means by which one travels toward (or away from) God; here the soul must face and conquer her disordered passions. The second step is Christ’s open side because here the soul encounters God’s heart in the depths of her own heart; here the soul covers herself in goodness. The third step is Christ’s mouth where the soul discovers the perfect peace of union with God’s will; here the soul relishes all things given by God, having won the battle against self-will. 
Having described the Bridge of Salvation, God expounds on the state, in this life (as well as in the next), of those who choose not to follow this way in contrast to those who do. Those headed for damnation are those who, “travel beneath the Bridge” in the, “river of disordered love.” God continues on in this chapter at great length, explaining to Catherine, the different things that the soul may encounter on its journey, warning her about pitfalls, and recommending to her the tools she must use to avoid them.
One example is worth noting for its practicality and humor. God described to Catherine how to fight against the wiles of the evil one, by preparing her with special knowledge of the devil’s ‘game-plan’ (so to speak) in attacking souls. God said the devil would either attempt to convince her that she is already perfect or that she is wretched beyond the reach of grace. God instructed her to counter these attacks by abasing herself in abject humility and taking refuge in his mercy. God assured her that the evil one would then finally give up in exasperation, exclaiming:
Damnable woman! There is no getting at you! If I throw you down in confusion you lift yourself up to mercy. If I exalt you you throw yourself down. You come even to hell in your humility, and even in hell you hound me. So I will not come back at you again, because you beat me with the cudgel of charity.


             

 In the fourth chapter, “Tears,” Catherine asked God to explain the soul’s journey to God with respect to the nature of the tears they shed at each stage along the way. There are five types of tears. Tears of damnation and servile fear belong to those who are not sorrowful over offending God but only for themselves. Imperfect tears belong to those who have made a break with sin for love of God but only imperfectly attain to virtue. Perfect tears belong to those souls who have wholly embraced God and neighbor in pure love. This last type of tears belongs also to those whom God blesses with an added grace-”sweet” tears of intimate union with himself.
The chapter, “Truth” is God’s response to Catherine’s request for a better understanding of judgement, particularly how she might guard herself against judging the sins of others and how she might judge whether an experience she has is from God. To this end, God presents another analogy of the three spiritual stages in the form of three ‘lights’ coming forth from himself. He illustrates the perfection (or lack thereof) of souls based upon their relation to himself as Supreme Truth.  He explained that judgement is reserved for himself and that a true vision does not leave one with an emotional high without producing fruit in holy actions, because what is from God can never be sterile.
            The next chapter, “Mystical Body of Holy Church,” concerns Catherine’s second petition, “for the reform of Holy Church.” This chapter details the sorts of corruption which were alive in the Catholic Church at the time. God tells Catherine at length of the dignity of the office with which his ministers are endowed and details how great a sin it is to disrespect one of his ministers, even though he may be clearly in sin. God tells of the many sins of corrupt priests and religious. There were those who practiced simony, those who kept mistresses openly, those who sought office for reasons of political advancement, and there were even those who pretended to consecrate the Eucharist because they feared divine judgement on account of their sins. Yet, again and again, God emphasizes to Catherine that the sins of the minster cannot effect the validity of the sacraments. 
            The second to last chapter, “Divine Providence,” is God’s response to Catherine’s fourth petition: for the provision of providence. In this discourse, God reveals the ways in which his Providence has perfectly provided everything that is necessary for every person in every circumstance.
In the last chapter, "Obedience," God speaks to Catherine of the perfections of Holy Obedience, describing it as a key which Christ used to open the gates of heaven again after Adam’s sin locked the gate. He instructs Catherine that each person must take up this key in imitation of Christ in order to reach eternal salvation.
Catherine’s Dialogue is without doubt a work written for the salvation of souls through the humble service of a “most beloved daughter” of God. The Church cannot thank her enough for opening her heart to God’s will so that she could become the conduit of rich blessings flowing from God’s heart.


Image Credits:












The Cloud of Unknowing: A Review


For many Catholics, the act of contemplating is a daunting task. The Cloud of Unknowing presents the reader with a way of prayer that is not customary to modern day Catholics. Awkwardness of approaching God through prayer has become a crisis in the Church. This easy to read book containing over seventy short, concise chapters provides the solution to starting this journey of an ongoing dialogue with Christ. The author states this book is for souls aspiring to contemplative prayer, not for those undisciplined seekers of the marvelous. Thought by many critics to have been a Cistercian monk during the Middle Ages, the author describes the stages of contemplation traveled by a soul desiring to enter God's presence. He humbly describes this work as an attempt to create a spiritual work for the reader and to instruct him how to construct it himself. 

God is found through contemplation and prayer. Accompanying this invitation to form a unique relationship with God must come humility. God asks the soul to claim our heritage, heaven, and humility demands us to forget the past and claim the future. Wanting only his love, God waits for the soul's cooperation to accomplish this work only in privacy, away from distractions. The soul is instructed to practice superior discipline, continuing in prayer even through the cloud of darkness going to God. Time is of the utmost importance: losing or gaining heaven is in one moment. When attempting contemplative prayer, senses and imagination are to be left behind. A pure, undivided love is the only way to pierce this cloud of unknowing about God. Contemplation is by no means a physical act; it is purely spiritual. The author humorously admonishes the act of looking up while praying as though one were to climb over the moon.

In reaching this level of contemplation in the cloud of unknowing, the soul should possess an industrious will, coupled with charity and humility. Imperfect humility begins with self-knowledge, admitting our sinful nature and recognizing the love of God. Perfect humility comes from firsthand experience of God’s goodness. Starting with imperfect humility, one has an awareness pushing away pride resulting from lack of knowledge. The perfectly humble person lacks for nothing. The more one loves, the more one wants to love. Divine contemplation already participates in eternity. Simply put, contemplation is a direct reaching out to God; it becomes a fulfillment of God’s Will.


Those who sincerely desire to leave the world should attempt contemplation. The first step of practicing contemplation is to purify the conscience by removing sins according to the practices of the Church. Our Lord gives his miracle of grace to those coming from a sinful life. Wanting to experience God on earth is an expression of love. God’s grace will assist the faithful soul through the way of contemplation. He withholds his grace sometimes, but He will never withdraw Himself from us. The next step in preparation is reading, reflection, and prayer. One cannot see his own frailty if he does not read the Word of God. Forgetfulness of self and supression of thoughts concerning subjects inferior to God is necessary for entering this cloud of approaching God. Sorrow of our past and a holy desire to joyfully receive the knowledge of God precedes a perfect union with Him. Although spiritual enthusiasm is necessary to attempt contemplation, humility strengthens the skill. A peaceful disposition of body and soul prepares the soul to love God joyfully and willingly. The physical aspects of prayer includes this peaceful disposition. As St. Paul said in his epistle on charity, we cannot do anything without love acting as our guide in the world. 
The author proceeds to the effects or results of contemplation. Contemplation destroys our impulse to sin more effectively than any other practice and motivates us to practice virtue. Contemplation knows no limits during one's lifetime. Those who practice contemplation become better companions to those around them, and others are attracted to this life of prayer. The contemplative soul knows how to govern himself and understand others, giving to them what he has received. The author makes the analogy between the division of the nose into two nostrils and the ability to see good and evil. Unlike the devil who only has one nostril for us to see hell at the end of his nose, we have two nostrils in order for us to distinguish between good and evil before making a judgment. 

The author encourages the reader to do his part, and God will discover the rest to him through this cloud of Divine Love. One must take the effort. Travel the challenging and narrow road to heaven, and resist the easy path to hell. The highway to heaven is to be measured in terms of desire, not miles. Reason and the power of the will must be used to desire the good and to achieve it. The reader is promised, if he continues contemplation, he will realize God's grace has obliterated many of his sins. True love, in this cloud of unknowing, contains all the virtues in the spiritual temple of God - the soul. Dionysius, a philosopher of the Middle Ages, sums up the message of The Cloud of Unknowing: "Whoso deserves to see and know God rests therein [in the darkness] and, by the very fact that he neither sees nor knows, is truly in that which surpasses all truth and all knowledge."

Image Credits:
"The Cloud of Unknowing", at The Cloud of Unknowing Google images
"Benedictine tradition", pamphlet at Our Lady of Guadalupe Monastery



Product Details can be found at Paraclete Press.



Holy Apostles College & Seminary 
Early Church Ecumenical Councils: A Timeline 
by
Mark Lenox
for 
Professor Heather Voccola, MA
CHH 300: Church History


Friday, June 29, 2018

Review: "The Confessions of Saint Augustine" (Tr. John K. Ryan)

The Confessions of Saint Augustine

Translated and with an Introduction and Notes by John K. Ryan

The Confessions of Saint Augustine is a classic among classic books. Autobiography,  theology, philosophy, drama, passionate prayer: this book has them all. It is autobiographical in nature, as it is told in the first person, however Augustine goes far deeper than simply relating the events of his life to the reader. I could not state it better than John K. Ryan does in his introduction to this book: "No writer ever went deeper, into his own character and deeds, passed keener judgments on himself, or revealed himself more fully and more humbly than others."[1]

It is important to consider the translation for Augustine's Confessions. In researching various possibilities, I found the most recommended version seems to be that of Frank Sheed. Peter Kreeft recommended, "Only once have I ever encountered a translation that made such a difference, that so opened up for me a previously closed book. That was Frank Sheed’s translation of Augustine’s Confessions, which I found to be as living as molten lava."[2] However, based on the recommendation of a friend, I decided on John K. Ryan's translation. The style of writing is clear and inspirational, and Ryan's edition includes a well-done Introduction, a timeline of Augustine's life, extensive reference notes, bibliography, index, and a study guide from the publisher.

The work is broken up into 13 books which are made up of short and shorter chapters. Books one through four deal with his early life. In it Augustine tells of his childhood, his sixteenth year, his later youth and the time he spent as a Manichean. In books five through eight, his spiritual struggles of early adulthood come to light in Rome and Milan, his years of struggle, his wrestling with different thoughts and beliefs, and his acceptance of grace and faith. His story culminates in book nine with  his conversion and a great tribute to his mother, Saint Monica. He then goes on with philosophical and theological ponderings and discoveries, speaking on memory, time and eternity, form and matter, and the creation of the world.

Augustine speaks of a number of characters in his book, and I found his focus on two aspects particularly notable. First are his friendships. He speaks in book 4 of the death of a dear friend, whom he played games with as a boy then grew to love dearly in his later youth. Later, in book 6, he dedicates four chapters to another friend, Alypius. Through these chapters, Augustine's deep friendships come through loud and clear and made me long for such in my own life.

The other moving tribute is to Augustine's mother, Monica. He dedicates no less than nine full chapters, along with parts of other chapters in various books, to her, His thoughts and feelings about his mother and her undeniable role in his life shines forth with undeniable clarity and moving rhetoric.

Not only is Augustine's candid self-assessment extraordinary, but also the style of the book. He writes it as one long 338 page prayer to God. In addition, the entire work is laced with scriptural quotes and references. While reading it, I got the impression that these biblical phrases are just part of how Augustine thinks and writes. There is no sense that he works at all to "fit" the scripture into the work, but rather they are just part of the natural flow of his discourse.

From the start, this is a book about searching for answers. In fact, the most famous quote from the saint is found in Book one, Chapter one, Paragraph one: "[O Lord], you have made us for yourself, and our heart is restless until it rests in you." This book is the story of a man frantically searching to end that restlessness. For anyone looking for extensive and deep - as well as prayerful - theological and philosophical insights of Catholic Christian thinking, Confessions is a must-read. In a "conversation" with God, Augustine takes the reader into questions, ponderings and musings that will stretch the mind, the heart and the soul.

[1] John K. Ryan, introduction to The Confessions of Saint Augustine, (New York: Image, 2014), xvii.
[2] Brandon Vogt, "The Best Translation of St. Augustine’s 'Confessions'," Brandon Vogt: Timeless Truths, New Media (blog), 06 April 2016, at brandonvogt.com.

Product Details

  • ISBN-10: 0385029551
  • ISBN-13: 978-0385029551
  • Paperback: 464 pages
  • Publisher: Image Edition 2014
  • Available on Amazon


Image Credits

Darren Booth, cover illustration, https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/51ZjC28qg9L._SX323_BO1,204,203,200_.jpg

Carlo Crivelli, "St. Augustine," painting, c. 1487, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Carlo_Crivelli_-_St._Augustine_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg

Ary Scheffer, "Saints Augustine and Monica," painting, 1846, https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/98/Saint_Augustine_and_Saint_Monica.jpg

Thursday, June 28, 2018

Chartres Cathedral


Christianity came to the ground of Chartres Cathedral by the first century AD. Before Christians began to inhabit Chartres, France, Druids living in the town offered their ceremonies to the gods around a particular well in the center of the town. The ground on which the cathedral stands was sacred to this cult who possessed a strong devotion to a particular Black Madonna, inevitably believed as the Virgin “who shall give birth”. The Druids persecuted the Christians as they began to move into Druid territory, and they accomplished this by throwing lay people and religious down the town well (as tall as a ten story building). The "Saints' Well", as it came to be called, proved to be miraculous from remains of martyrs in the water. [1] 


The whole cathedral of Chartres dates to the 8th century when the first church was set on fire and rebuilt. “One of the most completely surviving medieval churches”, Chartres stands up to this testimony due to existing 12th and 13th century stained glass and sculptures. After the choir around the main altar was finished in 1221, Chartres Cathedral was consecrated in 1260 "as one of the most compelling expressions of the strength and poetry of medieval Catholicism". [2] Spiritual intensity is great in the interior due to absence of direct light and its many stained glass windows. At the center of Chartres is seen the only labyrinth existing in France. This labyrinth signifies life, and, to the pilgrims who followed the design on their knees, it was symbolic of arriving at the new Jerusalem. The circle of the labyrinth signifies God: the Alpha and the Omega, no beginning and no end. The great rose window, seen above, is filled with symbolism pertaining to the Last Judgment. Christ, in the center, is surrounded with smaller windows portraying the four Evangelists; choirs of Angels, directly above Christ, announce His coming. Below Christ is seen St. Michael weighing the souls, the blessed seen on Christ's right, the damned on the left, with hell and limbo below. 


 Thirteenth century stained glass windows around the perimeter of the cathedral - 176 to be exact - illustrate Biblical history; these windows are responsible for naming the cathedral "the book of Chartres". Starting on the left side and ending on the right next to the main portal on the interior, the entire Bible is pictured in the windows; the reason for this was to teach the illiterate medieval population about the Faith. The north window, in the cold away from the sun, symbolizes the time of the Old Testament when civilization waited for the Messiah to come. Across the transept, the south window shows the warmth of the time of the New Testament after Christ was born. 


Romanesque and Gothic architecture contribute to the awe-inspiring cathedral. The Romanesque steeple at left is portrayed along with the 338 foot tall old bell tower with its many windows. The oldest and main portal of the cathedral dates to the mid-twelfth century. Twelfth century statues around the main door show Christ in His glory at the Last Judgment. Sculpted by Boudin in 1612, the Romanesque choir around the altar portrays forty-one scenes from the life of Our Lord. From the twelth to the thirteenth century, the nave was built, composed of seven bays. Gothic architecture is plainly seen on the east side of the cathedral by the many flying buttresses. Besides the buttresses, the style of many columns as support for the stone ceiling and pointed arches allow room for many windows. [3] 


Chartres is important in the religious and historical sense. In the crypt built by St. Fulbert between 1020 to 1024 (now the largest crypt in France) is a wall dating back to the third or fourth century from the Roman town of Chartres. Julius Caesar attests to this in his Gallic Wars, in which he describes the town of Carnutes as being the center of the Druids. [4] St. Bernard preached the First Crusade at Chartres. St. Louis Martin, father of St. Therese of Liseux, also made many pilgrimages to Chartres. The cathedral has been one of many landmarks of thousands of Santiago Compostella pilgrims since the Middle Ages. 
In St. Fulbert's crypt, Charles the Bald presented the cathedral with the Virgin's cloak in 876. The Blessed Mother's veil is housed behind the main altar. Below the church in the crypt is part of Our Lady's tunic She wore when Christ was born. Marian devotion increased greatly around the year 1000 that a certain bishop began the project of building a Romanesque cathedral dedicated to the Blessed Mother. 
Our Lady's Veil

A fire destroyed the cathedral in 1194, some historians believing the damage to be almost total, excluding the two towers in front. Had it not been for the courage of three priests rescuing the Virgin's veil and taking shelter in the crypt for three days and nights, the veil would have been lost entirely, diminishing the presence of future pilgrims to Chartres. In addition to the two Marian relics, the miraculous statue of Notre Dame du Pilier stands to the left of the main altar. Votive candles surround the statue of the Virgin and Her Son, now black from hundreds of years of candle smoke. As proof of the strong faith in the Blessed Mother beginning in the Middle Ages, hundreds of crutches stand on either side of the statue, attesting to many physical miracles; no doubt the spiritual miracles surpass that number. On the south side of the choir, to the right of the main altar is one of the stained glass windows that survived the 1194 fire. An object of great devotion, particularly to the pilgrims of the Middle Ages, this window is known as Notre Dame de la Belle Verriere (Our Lady of the Beautiful Window). [5] 


Scupltures around the main portal


Chartres is a temple of light, an insight of heaven on earth. Having visited the cathedral myself, I was struck with the enormous generosity of the people of the Middle Ages to sculpt and erect such an awe-inspiring structure for God. Even as I took this picture on the left, I stood in amazement at the complexity and beautiful detail of each image carved out of limestone. One interesting little detail is to be noticed in this picture: below the trimwork on the right can be seen the smiling face of a serpent. Studying the cathedral, one can become lost in thought as did the illiterate folk, studying their Faith as they looked at the stained glass windows and the sculptures around the altar and the exterior portals. "And many people shall go and say: Come and let us go up to the mountain  of the Lord and to the house of the God of Jacob, and he will teach us his ways, and we will walk in his paths." [6]










[1] Joan Gould, "Seeing the Light in Chartres", New York Times, (Dec. 18, 1988)
[2] Author unknown, "Chartres Cathedral", at ChartresCathedral.net. 
[3] Rick Steves, "Age of Faith lives on at Chartres", Chicago Tribune, (June 4, 2017)
[4] Joan Gould, "Seeing the Light in Chartres", New York Times, (Dec. 18, 1988)
[5] Fr. Johann Roten, "Chartres, the Belle-Verriere Window", University of Dayton, at https://udayton.edu/imri/mary/c/chartres-belle-verrire-window.php
[6] Isaiah 2:3